All shows at Maple Leaf Gardens and promoted by Frank Tunney unless otherwise noted.
| 65/01/03 Att: 7,000 |
| U.S. TITLE: |
| Johnny Valentine WCOR The Sheik | 11:49 |
| | to win the title |
| (Sheik's first Toronto loss) |
| Midgets: Tiny Tim/Sonny Boy Cassidy |
| W Sky Low Low/Fuzzy Cupid | 19:39 |
| (Cassidy subs for Jamaica Kid) |
| Terrible Ted (bear) W Jim Killer Conroy | 3:32 |
| Terrible Ted (bear) W Benny Lima | 7:08 |
| Sweet Daddy Siki W Joe Killer Christie | 16:04 |
| Michele Barone W Alexander the Great | 6:55 |
| Andy Robin WDec Duke Noble | 15:00 |
| Tony Parisi D Pat Flanagan | 15:00 |
| (subs for Chuck Conley) |
| Globe reports the crowd as 4,500 |
| |
| 65/01/10 Att: 5,500 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino |
| WCNC Waldo Von Erich | 24:16 |
| Chris Tolos/John Tolos |
| W Paul DeMarco/Andy Robin | 23:22 |
| The Beast W Tony Parisi | 20:13 |
| Michele Barone W Hurricane Smith | 1:45 |
| Johnny Powers W Johnny Foti | 8:09 |
| Pat Flanagan D Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/01/17 Att: 4,500 |
| U.S. TITLE: |
| Johnny Valentine D The Sheik | 25:47 |
| Chris Tolos/John Tolos |
| D Tex McKenzie/Johnny Barend | 30:00 |
| Waldo Von Erich W Duke Noble | 5:37 |
| (subs for Chuck Conley) |
| Johnny Powers W Tony Parisi | 11:14 |
| Hans Schmidt D Andy Robin | 15:00 |
| Michele Barone W Alexander the Great | 8:02 |
| (subs for Big Ike Eakins) |
| |
| 65/01/24 Att: 4,500 |
| Lord Athol Layton/Pat Flanagan |
| WDQ Chris Tolos/John Tolos | 13:52 |
| (Scheduled main event of a WWWF title match between Bruno Sammartino and Waldo Von Erich is scratched; Sammartino said to have been grounded in New York by bad weather) |
| Professor Hiro W Johnny Barend | 15:54 |
| Johnny Powers DCOR Hillbilly Conley | 5:52 |
| Tex McKenzie W Alexander the Great | 4:44 |
| Hans Schmidt D Andy Robin | 15:00 |
| Michele Barone W Joe Killer Christie | 7:29 |
| Johnny Kace D Paul DeMarco | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/01/31 Att: 4,800 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino W Waldo Von Erich | 10:32 |
| Johnny Valentine W Johnny Kace | 14:24 |
| The Beast D Tex McKenzie | 20:00 |
| Andy Robin W Alexander the Great | 12:51 |
| Johnny Powers W Paul DeMarco | 10:33 |
| Michele Barone W Johnny Carr | 6:09 |
| Hillbilly Chuck Conley |
| WCOR Joe Killer Christie | 9:54 |
| |
| 65/02/11 [Thurs] |
| Johnny Valentine W Bulldog Brower | 29:25 |
| Whipper Billy Watson W The Sheik | 11:06 |
| Chris Tolos/John Tolos |
| D Tex McKenzie/Hillbilly Chuck Conley | 20:00 |
| Johnny Powers W Alexander the Great | 3:03 |
| (subs for Johnny Barend) |
| The Beast D Andy Robin | 15:00 |
| Johnny Kace W Michele Barone | 10:28 |
| Pat Flanagan W Joe Killer Christie | 11:00 |
| |
| 65/02/18 [Thurs] Att: 4,000 |
| The Sheik W Tex McKenzie | 10:30 |
| Johnny Powers WCOR Andy Robin | 12:12 |
| Ilio DiPaolo/Michele Barone |
| D Chris Tolos/John Tolos (1-1) | 30:00 |
| Professor Hiro W Tony Parisi | 12:24 |
| Pat Flanagan W Johnny Kace | 7:24 |
| Paul DeMarco D Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/03/04 [Thurs] Att: 4,500 |
| Johnny Valentine WCOR Bulldog Brower | 23:39 |
| The Beast D Sweet Daddy Siki | 20:00 |
| Seaman Art Thomas W Joe Killer Christie | 7:26 |
| Fred Atkins/Professor Hiro |
| D Andy Robin/Michele Barone | 20:00 |
| Johnny Powers W Paul DeMarco | 11:39 |
| Tony Parisi D Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/03/07 |
| BRITISH EMPIRE TITLE: |
| Whipper Billy Watson WCOR Gene Kiniski |
| Johnny Valentine WDec The Beast | 20:00 |
| Johnny Powers W Andy Robin | 12:03 |
| Waldo Von Erich W Pat Flanagan | 6:27 |
| Sweet Daddy Siki W Joe Killer Christie |
| Fred Atkins D Michele Barone | 15:00 |
| Seaman Art Thomas |
| W Alexander the Great | 7:57 |
| |
| 65/03/18 [Thurs] Att: 3,500 |
| $1,000 IF POWERLOCK IS BROKEN: |
| Johnny Powers W Sweet Daddy Siki | 16:31 |
| Fred Atkins/Professor Hiro |
| W Chris Tolos/Ilio DiPaolo | 17:29 |
| (subs for John Tolos) |
| The Beast D Andy Robin | 20:00 |
| Seaman Art Thomas W Joe Killer Christie | 13:23 |
| Michele Barone |
| W Alexander the Great | 10:30 |
| Paul DeMarco D Tony Parisi | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/03/21 |
| BRITISH EMPIRE TITLE: |
| Whipper Billy Watson WDQ Gene Kiniski | 12:39 |
| (Waldo Von Erich interferes) |
| Johnny Valentine |
| W Joe Killer Christie | 15:33 |
| Waldo Von Erich W Sweet Daddy Siki | 22:53 |
| The Beast D Andy Robin | 20:00 |
| Fred Atkins W Michele Barone | 15:00 |
| Seaman Art Thomas |
| W Alexander the Great | 7:23 |
| |
| 65/03/28 |
| Gene Kiniski/Waldo Von Erich |
| W Whipper Billy Watson/ |
| Johnny Valentine | 20:41 |
| (Kiniski and Von Erich are the U.S. tag champions in Washington, DC) |
| Sweet Daddy Siki/Seaman Art Thomas |
| D Professor Hiro/Fred Atkins (1-1) | 30:00 |
| The Beast D Michele Barone | 15:00 |
| Andy Robin W Tony Parisi | 11:18 |
| Paul DeMarco D Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/04/04 |
| U.S. TITLE: |
| Johnny Valentine W The Beast | 22:06 |
| Whipper Billy Watson |
| WCOR Bulldog Brower | 12:28 |
| (Watson subs for WWWF champion Bruno Sammartino) |
| Fred Atkins/Professor Hiro |
| D Andy Robin/Michele Barone | 20:00 |
| Seaman Art Thomas D Ilio DiPaolo | 15:00 |
| Pat Flanagan WDQ Joe Killer Christie | 9:59 |
| Tony Parisi WDec Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/04/11 Att: 3,500 |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Johnny Valentine |
| W Gene Kiniski/Waldo Von Erich | 16:41 |
| The Beast/Professor Hiro |
| D Michele Barone/Andy Robin (1-1) | 30:00 |
| Seaman Art Thomas WDQ Bob Leipler | 9:56 |
| Fred Atkins D Paul DeMarco | 20:00 |
| Victor Rivera WDec Alexander the Great | 20:00 |
| |
| 65/04/18 Att: 3,500 |
| Johnny Valentine WDQ Bulldog Brower | 17:00 |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Haystacks Calhoun |
| WCOR Professor Hiro/Fred Atkins | 8:50 |
| Midgets: Sonny Boy Cassidy/ |
| Cowboy Bradley |
| W Fuzzy Cupid/Billy the Kid (2-1) |
| The Beast D Andy Robin | 20:00 |
| Michele Barone WDec Mike Valentino | 20:00 |
| |
| 65/04/25 Att: 5,100 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino WDQ Johnny Powers | 9:58 |
| (manager Martino Angelo interferes) |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Karl Gotch |
| W Professor Hiro/The Beast | 10:38 |
| (Gotch subs for injured Johnny Valentine; Beast managed by Martino Angelo) |
| Pat Flanagan W Alexander the Great | 13:26 |
| Seaman Art Thomas WDQ Fred Atkins | 16:07 |
| Michele Barone D Bob Leipler | 15:00 |
| Victor Rivera D Jerry London | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/05/16 |
| Johnny Powers |
| WCOR Whipper Billy Watson | 10:17 |
| (subs for Johnny Valentine) |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Karl Gotch |
| W Fritz Von Erich/The Beast | 19:10 |
| Lord Athol Layton W Mike Valentino |
| (subs for Joe Killer Christie) |
| Andy Robin W Duke Noble | 8:39 |
| Victor Rivera D Bob Leipler | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/05/27 [Thurs] |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Karl Gotch |
| W Johnny Powers/The Beast | 27:03 |
| Midgets: Roger Littlebrook/Pancho Lopez |
| W Sky Low Low/Fuzzy Cupid | 25:51 |
| (Littlebrook subs for Irish Jackie) |
| Alexander the Great D Joey London | 20:00 |
| Stamford Murphy W Victor Rivera | 15:56 |
| (Murphy formerly known as Gene Murphy) |
| Andy Robin W Mike Valentino | 10:58 |
| |
| 65/06/17 [Thurs] Att: 3,500 |
| TEXAS DEATH MATCH: |
| Johnny Powers W Whipper Billy Watson | 9:31 |
| (Powers accompanied by Alexander the Great) |
| Paul DeMarco/Andy Robin |
| D The Beast/Alexander the Great (1-1) | 30:00 |
| Stamford Murphy W Jerry London | 12:04 |
| Fred Atkins W Victor Rivera | 12:46 |
| Pat Flanagan WCOR Duke Noble | 11:42 |
| |
| 65/06/24 [Thurs] |
| Whipper Billy Watson |
| W Alexander The Great (2-0) | 32:42 |
| (subs for Johnny Powers, said to have been injured in a car accident on Tuesday; crowd was asked to choose between Schmidt and Alexander for main event) |
| Professor Hiro/Fred Atkins |
| W Paul DeMarco/Andy Robin | 18:19 |
| Karl Gotch/Seaman Art Thomas |
| W The Beast/Martino Angelo | 15:05 |
| Hans Schmidt W Victor Rivera | 14:51 |
| Tony Marino D Stamford Murphy | 20:00 |
| |
| 65/07/08 [Thurs] Att: 2,500 |
| Maple Leaf Stadium |
| NWA TITLE: |
| Lou Thesz W Professor Hiro | 14:13 |
| Midgets: Cowboy Bradley/ |
| Sonny Boy Cassidy |
| W Billy The Kid/Wild Red Taylor | 12:40 |
| Johnny Valentine W Hans Schmidt | 15:09 |
| Karl Gotch W Joe Killer Christie | 12:21 |
| The Beast D Andy Robin | 20:00 |
| Tony Marino W Mike Valentino | 13:29 |
| |
| 65/07/15 [Thurs] Att: 3,000 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino |
| WCOR Johnny Powers | 13:35 |
| Midgets: Cowboy Bradley/ |
| Sonny Boy Cassidy |
| W Irish Jackie/Billy The Kid | 16:57 |
| Johnny Valentine W Fred Atkins | 14:00 |
| Andy Robin D Stamford Murphy | 20:00 |
| The Beast W Victor Rivera | 11:12 |
| Tony Marino W Duke Noble | 18:15 |
| |
| 65/07/29 [Thurs] Att: 4,000 |
| Maple Leaf Stadium |
| NWA TITLE: |
| Lou Thesz D Whipper Billy Watson | 23:58 |
| Gene Kiniski W Stamford Murphy | 12:52 |
| Johnny Valentine/Sweet Daddy Siki |
| W Professor Hiro/Bob Leipler | 25:47 |
| Midgets: Sky Low Low/Billy the Kid |
| D Jamaica Kid/Cowboy Bradley | 30:00 |
| Andy Robin W Apache Pete Mingo | 10:23 |
| |
| 65/08/05 [Thurs] Att: 3,000 |
| Maple Leaf Stadium |
| BRITISH EMPIRE TITLE: |
| Whipper Billy Watson WDQ Gene Kiniski | 11:24 |
| Midgets: Pancho Lopez/ |
| Sonny Boy Cassidy |
| W Fuzzy Cupid/Irish Jackie (2-1) | 40:00 |
| Johnny Powers W Andy Robin | 12:06 |
| Professor Hiro/The Beast |
| W Paul DeMarco/Jerry London | 22:15 |
| Bob Leipler W Apache Pete Mingo | 16:09 |
| |
| 65/08/12 [Thurs] |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Sweet Daddy Siki |
| W Johnny Powers/The Beast | 14:48 |
| Professor Hiro W Jerry London | 19:03 |
| Seaman Art Thomas W Bob Leipler | 9:03 |
| Tony Marino W Joe Killer Christie | 16:35 |
| Andy Robin WDec Mike Valentino | 20:00 |
| |
| 65/08/19 [Thurs] |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Johnny Valentine |
| W Gene Kiniski/Waldo Von Erich | 14:14 |
| Professor Hiro W Andy Robin | 13:09 |
| Seaman Art Thomas W Stamford Murphy | 15:56 |
| The Beast W Jerry London | 10:41 |
| Tony Marino W Joe Killer Christie | 15:22 |
| Bob Leipler D Tony Manous | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/08/26 [Thurs] |
| Gene Kiniski/Professor Hiro |
| W Whipper Billy Watson/ |
| Johnny Valentine | 15:49 |
| The Beast W George Ringo | 8:21 |
| Andy Robin W Mike Valentino | 9:15 |
| Seaman Art Thomas |
| W Alexander the Great | 14:31 |
| Tony Marino W Apache Pete Mingo | 13:46 |
| Tony Manous D Stamford Murphy | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/09/02 [Thurs] Att: 6,000 |
| BRITISH EMPIRE TITLE: |
| Whipper Billy Watson |
| WDQ Gene Kiniski | 15:21 |
| (Professor Hiro interferes) |
| Professor Hiro W Seaman Art Thomas | 10:58 |
| Tony Marino W Apache Pete Mingo | 17:05 |
| Andy Robin W Stamford Murphy | 11:24 |
| Paul DeMarco D Bob Leipler | 20:00 |
| Pat Flanagan WDec Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/09/09 [Thurs] Att: 2,300 |
| Whipper Billy Watson |
| WDQ Professor Hiro | 18:14 |
| (accompanied by Fred Atkins) |
| Johnny Powers W Andy Robin | 13:39 |
| Tony Marino W Stamford Murphy | 16:18 |
| Jerry London D Bob Leipler | 20:00 |
| Paul DeMarco WDec Joe Killer Christie | 15:00 |
| Fred Atkins W Johnny Foti | 8:36 |
| |
| 65/09/16 [Thurs] Att: 3,500 |
| NWA TITLE: |
| Lou Thesz W Johnny Valentine | 21:35 |
| Johnny Powers W Paul DeMarco | 10:32 |
| Sweet Daddy Siki W Bob Leipler | 10:57 |
| The Beast/Professor Hiro |
| D Andy Robin/Jerry London | 20:00 |
| Tiger Jeet Singh W Stamford Murphy | 4:12 |
| Hans Schmidt D Tony Marino | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/09/26 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino WDQ Johnny Powers | 16:18 |
| Seaman Art Thomas/Sweet Daddy Siki |
| W Hans Schmidt/Bob Leipler | 22:33 |
| Professor Hiro W Paul DeMarco | 21:07 |
| The Beast W Jerry London | 14:41 |
| Tiger Jeet Singh W Pat Flanagan | 0:50 |
| Georgios Kanelis W Alexander the Great | 11:17 |
| |
| 65/10/03 |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Johnny Powers |
| W Gene Kiniski/Professor Hiro | 18:30 |
| Lord Athol Layton W Joe Killer Christie | 14:26 |
| The Beast D Sweet Daddy Siki | 20:00 |
| Tiger Jeet Singh W Jerry London | 1:49 |
| Tony Marino WDec Mike Valentino | 20:00 |
| Georgios Kanelis W George Allen | 13:56 |
| |
| 65/10/21 [Thurs] Att: 3,000 |
| Gene Kiniski W Johnny Powers | 17:48 |
| Lord Athol Layton W Alexander the Great |
| Professor Hiro W Paul DeMarco |
| Tony Marino DDQ Mike Valentino |
| Tiger Jeet Singh W Johnny Foti |
| Emile Dupre WDec Bob Leipler |
| |
| 65/10/28 [Thurs] Att: 3,500 |
| Gene Kiniski WCNC Johnny Powers | 9:10 |
| Lord Athol Layton W Mike Valentino | 12:43 |
| Professor Hiro W Johnny Powers | 16:42 |
| Seaman Art Thomas D Waldo Von Erich | 20:00 |
| The Beast W Tony Marino | 14:21 |
| Masked Yankees: Doodle/Dandy |
| W Emile Dupre/Paul DeMarco | 16:11 |
| Also advertised: Tiger Jeet Singh, Johnny Rougeau |
| |
| 65/11/07 Att: 6,000 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino WDQ Bulldog Brower | 13:51 |
| Mighty Yankees |
| W Sweet Daddy Siki/Stamford Murphy | 22:38 |
| Tiger Jeet Singh W Paul DeMarco | 5:34 |
| Professor Hiro W Tony Parisi | 13:43 |
| Georgios Kanelis WDQ Bob Leipler | 15:14 |
| Emile Dupre WDec Alexander the Great | 15:00 |
| |
| 65/11/21 |
| BRITISH EMPIRE TITLE: |
| Whipper Billy Watson |
| W Gene Kiniski (2-1) | 57:00 |
| Masked Yankees |
| W Sweet Daddy Siki/Tony Parisi | 14:19 |
| Emile Dupre WDec Joe Killer Christie | 20:00 |
| (Dupre billed as Maritimes champion) |
| Tiger Jeet Singh W Bob Leipler | 8:36 |
| Georgios Kanelis WDQ Tarzan Tyler | 15:56 |
| Professor Hiro W Paul DeMarco | 16:57 |
| |
| 65/11/28 |
| Johnny Powers/Sweet Daddy Siki |
| W Professor Hiro/Tiger Jeet Singh (2-1) |
| Masked Yankees |
| W Emile Dupre/Tony Marino | 21:09 |
| Tony Parisi WDec Alexander the Great | 20:00 |
| Georgios Kanelis W Stamford Murphy | 18:15 |
| Pat Flanagan W Bob Leipler | 11:17 |
| |
| 65/12/05 Att: 5,000 |
| WWWF TITLE: |
| Bruno Sammartino |
| WCOR Bulldog Brower | 20:48 |
| Masked Yankees |
| W Seaman Art Thomas/Paul DeMarco | 22:58 |
| Johnny Valentine DCOR Waldo Von Erich | 17:59 |
| Professor Hiro/Tiger Jeet Singh |
| W Sweet Daddy Siki/Tony Parisi | 24:05 |
| Georgios Kanelis W Kangaroo Kennedy | 15:59 |
| |
| 65/12/26 Att: 5,000 |
| Whipper Billy Watson/Lord Athol Layton |
| WDQ Masked Yankees | 21:05 |
| Midgets: Roger Littlebrook/Little Beaver |
| W Tiny Tim/Pancho Lopez (2-1) |
| Johnny Valentine W Waldo Von Erich | 5:52 |
| Professor Hiro/Tiger Jeet Singh |
| W Sweet Daddy Siki/Georgios Kanelis | 14:02 |
| Seaman Art Thomas W Bob Leipler | 11:16 |
| Pat Flanagan W Alexander the Great | 12:04 |
| |
